Manhattan Gold & Silver Logo

History of the Susan B. Anthony Dollar Coin and Why It Failed to Gain Popularity

Have you ever come across a Susan B Anthony dollar coin in your spare change and wondered why it’s so uncommon compared to other coins? Despite being a step forward for representation in currency, the Susan B. Anthony dollar coin failed to gain popularity and remains a rare find in circulation. Today, we’ll delve into the history of the coin as well as the reasons behind its lack of public appeal. By the end, you’ll have a better understanding of why this coin, while not widely used, holds an important place in history.

The History of the Susan B. Anthony Coin

The Susan B. Anthony coin was first minted in 1979 as a replacement for the Eisenhower dollar coin. Several coin shapes and compositions were tested but opposed by the vending machine lobby prior to the final selection of a round blank. The coin was designed by the Chief Engraver of the US Mint, Frank Gasparro. The front of the coin shows the side profile of Susan B. Anthony while the back of the coin shows the Apollo 11 insignia – the same as the back of the Eisenhower coin.

The first Susan B. Anthony dollars were struck at the Philadelphia Mint in December 1978. Mint officials feared that demand for the coin would outweigh supply and proactively had over 750 million coins produced for circulation. Unfortunately, the coin was not as well received as Mint officials had predicted.

Design and Confusion with Quarters

A major factor contributing to the confusion surrounding the Susan B. Anthony dollar coin was its design, which bore a striking resemblance to the quarter. While the coin features an eleven-sided inner border, the overall appearance of the coin made it easy to mistake it for a quarter, leading to challenges in both circulation and acceptance.

Lack of Public Awareness and Marketing

Another factor that contributed to the failure of the Susan B Anthony dollar coin was the lack of public awareness and effective marketing campaigns. Despite its historical significance as the first US coin to feature a woman, the coin failed to capture the attention of the public. Without proper education and promotion, many people were unaware of the coin’s existence or its value, ultimately leading to low usage and acceptance rates in everyday transactions.

This disconnect between the coin’s intended message and the public’s perception highlights the importance of effective communication and marketing strategies in promoting new forms of currency. With more efforts made to educate the public, the Susan B. Anthony dollar coin may have had a better chance at overcoming the challenges it faced.

Resistance to Change and Preference for Paper Currency

Many Americans were resistant to change, particularly when it came to their preferences for traditional paper currency over dollar coins. The familiarity and convenience of bills was deeply ingrained in society, making it difficult for a new form of currency to gain traction.

The limited acceptance and use of the Susan B. Anthony dollar coin not only reflected a resistance to change but also highlighted the need for effective communication and promotion strategies to shift public perceptions. By addressing these barriers and implementing targeted efforts to educate and inform the public, the coin could have potentially overcome its initial struggles in gaining widespread popularity and acceptance.

Legacy in Numismatic History

Despite these challenges, the Susan B. Anthony coin remains a notable piece in numismatic history, offering valuable insights into the complexities of introducing a new currency into circulation. Its brief and tumultuous time in the spotlight serves as a reminder of the importance of considering public perception, distribution strategies, and the cultural significance of a coin when attempting to introduce it into the market.

Bringing It All Together

The Susan B. Anthony coin has significance in American numismatics for a handful of reasons including:

  • This coin was the first to feature a non-fictional woman and the release coincided with the 20th century women’s rights movement
  • The Susan B. Anthony dollar while silver in color was made from copper and nickel while being smaller than the previously released Eisenhower dollar

The coin’s influence can’t be debated; the next dollar coin, the Sacagawea dollar is a similar size but is a golden color to prevent confusion of the dollar coin and quarters. Despite not reaching its predicted popularity, the coin symbolizes change in American coinage.

Skip to content